Compare this hotel
Black Ivy vs New Town Guest House (Adults Only)
Side-by-side comparison of two hotels in Edinburgh — score, location, comfort and price.
VS
Comparing Black Ivy to New Town Guest House (Adults Only) in Edinburgh. It's neck and neck, and it comes down to reviews and confidence versus raw value for money.
Toss-up
Pick based on gut feeling — the numbers can't separate these two in Edinburgh.
If you only remember one thing
With scores of 70.87 and 70.95, this comparison is essentially a draw. Your priorities, not our numbers, should decide.
Choose Black Ivy
- You want the hotel more travelers have validated
- You want to step outside and be in the center
- You want to feel the difference when you walk in
- Facilities and convenience matter to you
Choose New Town Guest House (Adults Only)
- Saving money without losing quality is the goal
Score comparison
| Dimension | Black Ivy | New Town Guest House (Adults Only) |
|---|---|---|
| Reputation | 92.30 | 90.20 |
| Value | 51.87 | 70.94 |
| Location | 71.55 | 66.91 |
| Comfort | 81.80 | 65.20 |
| Services | 55.00 | 50.00 |
| Overall | 70.87 | 70.95 |
Detailed analysis
Reputation: On Reputation, Black Ivy leads slightly with a 2.1-point margin.
Value: On Value, New Town Guest House (Adults Only) leads clearly with a 19.07-point margin.
Location: On Location, Black Ivy leads slightly with a 4.64-point margin.
Comfort: On Comfort, Black Ivy leads clearly with a 16.6-point margin.
Services: On Services, Black Ivy leads slightly with a 5-point margin.
Price
Black Ivy
EUR 235
Small Double Room
New Town Guest House (Adults Only)
EUR 145
Double Room with Private External Bathroom
Facilities
Both hotels
Free Wifi
Only Black Ivy
Facilities for disabled guestsFamily roomsNon-smoking roomsParkingPet friendlyRestaurantRoom serviceWifi in all areas
Only New Town Guest House (Adults Only)
CCTV in common areasCCTV outside propertyFire extinguishersInternetSafeShared lounge/TV areaSmoke-free property