Compare this hotel
Malmaison Edinburgh City vs New Town Guest House (Adults Only)
Side-by-side comparison of two hotels in Edinburgh — score, location, comfort and price.
VS
This Edinburgh matchup — Malmaison Edinburgh City versus New Town Guest House (Adults Only) — is neck and neck. The core dynamic: two hotels with genuinely different strengths.
Toss-up
Too close to call on data alone. Both are legitimate options in Edinburgh.
If you only remember one thing
A 0.57-point gap between Malmaison Edinburgh City and New Town Guest House (Adults Only). That's noise, not signal. Both work. Pick on feel.
Choose Malmaison Edinburgh City
- Being close to the action is non-negotiable
- Room quality matters more than location or price
Choose New Town Guest House (Adults Only)
- You're optimizing for value over extras
Score comparison
| Dimension | Malmaison Edinburgh City | New Town Guest House (Adults Only) |
|---|---|---|
| Reputation | 90.20 | 90.20 |
| Value | 50.47 | 70.94 |
| Location | 83.38 | 66.91 |
| Comfort | 81.20 | 65.20 |
| Services | 50.00 | 50.00 |
| Overall | 71.52 | 70.95 |
Detailed analysis
Reputation: Reputation is essentially tied between the two.
Value: Value goes to New Town Guest House (Adults Only), clearly (20.47 pts gap).
Location: Location goes to Malmaison Edinburgh City, clearly (16.47 pts gap).
Comfort: Comfort goes to Malmaison Edinburgh City, clearly (16 pts gap).
Services: Services is essentially tied between the two.
Price
Malmaison Edinburgh City
EUR 307
Cozy Double
New Town Guest House (Adults Only)
EUR 145
Double Room with Private External Bathroom
Facilities
Both hotels
Free Wifi
Only Malmaison Edinburgh City
Facilities for disabled guestsFamily roomsNon-smoking roomsPet friendlyRestaurantRoom serviceWifi in all areas
Only New Town Guest House (Adults Only)
CCTV in common areasCCTV outside propertyFire extinguishersInternetSafeShared lounge/TV areaSmoke-free property