Compare this hotel
New Town Guest House (Adults Only) vs Kimpton Charlotte Square by IHG
Side-by-side comparison of two hotels in Edinburgh — score, location, comfort and price.
VS
New Town Guest House (Adults Only) and Kimpton Charlotte Square by IHG in Edinburgh: a real contest, shaped by reviews and confidence versus raw value for money.
Moderate confidence
Kimpton Charlotte Square by IHG edges this one out (classic tradeoff: guest confidence vs. better value). But New Town Guest House (Adults Only) has its own appeal if priorities shift.
If you only remember one thing
Kimpton Charlotte Square by IHG edges ahead at 78.37/100 versus 70.95/100 — a 7.42-point gap. Enough to notice, not enough to dismiss New Town Guest House (Adults Only).
Choose New Town Guest House (Adults Only)
- Your budget is the priority — you want the best rate
Choose Kimpton Charlotte Square by IHG
- You trust the crowd — reviews matter more to you than anything
- You'd rather walk than take a taxi
- A good night's sleep is worth paying for
- On-site amenities make your stay easier
Score comparison
| Dimension | New Town Guest House (Adults Only) | Kimpton Charlotte Square by IHG |
|---|---|---|
| Reputation | 90.20 | 92.30 |
| Value | 70.94 | 56.49 |
| Location | 66.91 | 80.03 |
| Comfort | 65.20 | 97.80 |
| Services | 50.00 | 70.00 |
| Overall | 70.95 | 78.37 |
Detailed analysis
Reputation: Kimpton Charlotte Square by IHG takes Reputation by 2.1 points — slightly ahead.
Value: New Town Guest House (Adults Only) takes Value by 14.45 points — noticeably ahead.
Location: Kimpton Charlotte Square by IHG takes Location by 13.12 points — noticeably ahead.
Comfort: Kimpton Charlotte Square by IHG takes Comfort by 32.6 points — clearly ahead.
Services: Kimpton Charlotte Square by IHG takes Services by 20 points — clearly ahead.
Price
New Town Guest House (Adults Only)
EUR 145
Double Room with Private External Bathroom
Kimpton Charlotte Square by IHG
EUR 264
Single City Room
Facilities
Both hotels
Free Wifi
Only New Town Guest House (Adults Only)
CCTV in common areasCCTV outside propertyFire extinguishersInternetSafeShared lounge/TV areaSmoke-free property
Only Kimpton Charlotte Square by IHG
1 swimming poolFacilities for disabled guestsFamily roomsFitness centerNon-smoking roomsParking on sitePet friendlyPrivate ParkingRestaurantRoom serviceSpa